Picture this: a beloved K-pop idol, adored by millions, suddenly faces a wave of online criticism for her performance. Yes, that’s the reality for TWICE’s Mina after fans shared clips from the group’s latest concert in Seoul, igniting a firestorm of debate online.

Recently, the iconic girl group TWICE kicked off their sixth world tour, titled THIS IS FOR, with electrifying shows that had fans buzzing with excitement. They performed an array of beloved hits along with fresh tracks from their new album, captivating audiences in a way only TWICE can. But amidst the cheers, a troubling narrative began to unfold.

Known for their stunning choreography and infectious energy, TWICE typically dazzles fans with synchronized performances. However, a fan-recorded clip of Mina during the song “Feel Special” struck a different chord. Viewers couldn’t help but notice that Mina appeared less energetic than her fellow members, leading to a barrage of criticism online.

Comments poured in from international fans, some claiming that she seemed sluggish and lacked the vibrant stage presence expected of a K-pop idol. One social media user lamented, “go girl give us nothing,” capturing the essence of the disappointment felt by some fans. Another clip of Mina dancing during “Dance The Night Away” further fueled the debate, with critics and defenders alike taking to social media.

As clips circulated, discussions erupted. Some fans rallied behind Mina, arguing that the rigorous demands of concerts could understandably affect performance levels. Others, however, insisted that idols must maintain a certain level of energy, no matter the circumstances, suggesting that it’s part of the job description.

“Como era?? 'El primer concierto y ya están cansadas'” one user remarked, questioning if the group was already showing signs of fatigue so early in the tour. Another chimed in with a pointed jab, saying, “Se nota que detesta a su grupo” — implying that Mina’s lack of enthusiasm indicated she didn’t care for her fellow members.

Even the group’s longevity hasn’t shielded them from scrutiny. As the band has been performing for a decade, fans felt disheartened to witness what they perceived as a lack of stage presence from all the members. One critical voice noted, “The only thing that's saving them is the amount of members,” suggesting that if only a few were on stage, their energy levels would be even more starkly noticeable.

This incident comes on the heels of a similar controversy involving BLACKPINK's Jennie, who was criticized for her performance during a concert in LA. Fans noted that despite Jennie adjusting her mic pack, the backlash was fierce. As more clips from TWICE's shows emerge, fans are left pondering: Are the physical and mental demands of modern idol life becoming too overwhelming? While some express disappointment, others are calling for empathy, urging followers to appreciate the grueling effort behind the glamour.