What if a simple wave changed the course of a couple's relationship forever? That’s exactly what Sophie Turner claims happened over a decade ago, and the internet is buzzing with guesses about who the couple might be.

During a recent appearance on Late Night with Seth Meyers, the Game of Thrones star opened up about an unforgettable night at Comic-Con that spiraled into chaos. It was her first time at the famed convention, and she recounts, “That night was actually quite crazy for me, it went really south really quick.” She went on to explain that she can’t name names—after all, who wants to invite trouble?

Accompanied by her childhood friend, Sophie was encouraged to say hi to an actor whom her friend admired. A simple wave was all it took to set off what would become a whirlwind of speculation. “Later on,” Sophie recalls, “I see this girl looking at me, and she’s a famous actress. And I was like, ‘I have to go and tell her how much she means to me.’ So I dance on over and she goes, ‘Can you stop f–king flirting with my fiancé?’”

With an innocent question about the identity of the fiancé, Sophie discovered that it was the very man she had waved at moments before. “I have no idea who this man is,” she confessed on the talk show. To her shock, this seemingly harmless interaction may have led to the couple’s breakup that night. “Turns out, I think they broke their engagement off that night because of my [wave],” she added, astonished at the power she unknowingly wielded.

Fans, ever the detectives, believe they’ve cracked the case, speculating that the couple in question was none other than Emma Roberts and Evan Peters. The two were seen together at Comic-Con in 2014, and their tumultuous relationship is well-known, with ups and downs that included Emma's 2013 arrest and their eventual engagement.

After examining timelines and party photos, fans on Reddit concluded, “The streets are saying it’s Emma Roberts and Evan Peters, which tracks.” This speculation fits the narrative perfectly, as Emma and Evan faced a rocky road together, officially calling off their engagement in 2015, only to reconcile a year later.

Interestingly, Sophie and Evan later crossed paths in Hollywood, collaborating on the X-Men franchise in both X-Men: Apocalypse (2016) and Dark Phoenix (2019). While there’s no concrete evidence linking Sophie’s wave to Emma and Evan’s breakup, the timing and details sure do align with the story's mystery.

As for Sophie, she seems to have moved on from the past, now rekindling a romance with a recent ex. It’s a strange twist of fate that leaves fans wondering just how much power a casual wave can hold.